Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts

Saturday, December 13, 2008

Handmade Nation

Faythe Levine of Paper Boat Gallery has put togehter a book and documentary film that wonderfully introduces readers and viewers to the D I Y craft scene. The film isn't out yet, but the previews look great. I got myself a copy of the book and thoroughly enjoy it.

This book is really wonderful cuz the authors (Cortney Heimerl co-authors the book) leave the makers to speak for themselves. It offers glimpses into the variety of motives, methods and mediums being explored in this movement, as well as a handful of informative essays from various participants. There's also a great timeline that visually outlines the rapid growth of the "new wave of craft".

What this book might mean for the theory of "artist's revolution" i am attempting to develop:

1. Art vs Craft - The ideas and actions contained in this book indicate a new relationship between the individual 'maker' and the art world. Many of the interviewed subjects come from an art school background, often with regrets. These people are often hesitant to call themselves artists and almost uniformly skeptical of "fine art" and all it's institutional trappings. The fact that they've abandoned the word "artist" and replaced it with "crafter" or even "maker" amplifies my suspicion that the word "art" must be either eschewed or carefully redefined for use in my theory.

2. Economics of Craft - There is a hole in my theory. A major peice of my argument is that the growing arts and entertainment sector (especially experience based mediums) will empower the radical creative class in the same way that the growing importance of commodities empowered the early bourgeoisie. That this empowered creative class will usher in a new mode of production on the wave of A+E demand in the same way that the bourgeoisie ushered in capitalism on the wave of commodity exchange.

The hole in this theory comes from the difficulty of seeing how musicians and theatre producers might create innovative modes of production of find efficiencies that can transfer to other sectors in the same way the capitalism transferred from commodities to agriculture (feudalism's strong suit). How is what's going on today in the punk rock scene going to change the way that my kitchen utensils my meals, or my car are produced? In terms of agriculture, food coops and the rise of organic farming offer some support, but what about commodities?

Well, the craft movement isn't making cars, or flatware, but they are making clothes and various other utilitarian objects using something like the modes of production and exchange that started becoming popular in the punk rock and indie music scenes. I still think the new mode of production will be most thoroughly developed in mediums of live performance first, and then transfer to other areas, but when it does, Handmade Nation indicates that there's an army of people already trying to stitch a patch over this hole in the theory.

3. Craftivism - many makers are overt with their political motivations, and this has potential to bolster the poltical aspect of the revolution more than traditional political action. The medium is the message. A theatre peice, a painting or a song about sweatshop labor can't make a statement anywhere near as clear and complete as the maker who hand sews an alternative to the sweatshop product.

4. Technology and craft - the new wave of craft is held together by internet connections. Websites, message boards, emails, online shops, all establish the initial network (and generate many of the sales) that lay the groundwork for the huge explosion of craft starting in the late 90s. This is a wonderful example of creative people using the internet the right way: to coordinate and dissiminate real world physical objects. The internet as a platform or medium for content (you tube, video games, online stories, webcomix, and especially social networking sites like myspace) can only provide distractions, estrangement, and highly mediated entertainment or information. The internet as organizational tool to connect people trying to build something in real life, is immense and revolutionary.

5. The Church of Craft- I often neglect the "spiritual" component of a revolutionary change. I have huge problems with the terms used to talk about this level of human experience. But i have to admit that it is important. If the protestant work ethic and the capitalist mode of production were mutually reinforcing developments that helped birth capitalism, then the "artist revolution" needs it's own mutually reinforcing spiritual component. There are many examples and articulations of this kind of thing, but Handmade Nation includes an essay by Callie Janoff, founder of "The Church of Craft" which is a full blown religious institution that meets regularly, builds things together, and even officiates crafty weddings. There is no doctrine, no moral code, just people who feel the most divine when they're creating something.

Saturday, November 1, 2008

Review - Six Characters

I just want to quickly state that the UWM labworks production of Pirandello's Six Characters in Search of an Author is definitely worth seeing.

These students might not have the training or the polish that UWM mainstage productions have, but some of them have more rawness and passion than i'm used to seeing out of UWM actors. Especially noteworthy are Tommy Stevens, Callie Eberdt and Max Hultquist, but singling them out is a bit unfair, because others' roles were much smaller or intended to be less passionate. These students have committed more deeply to their characters and to this challenging play than most of what comes out of UWMs programs, and it pays off, making this a truly effecting and successful adaptation of Pirandello.

Ben Wilson's inclusion of Milwaukee-specific lines in the script also rung true to frustrations with the arts in milwaukee. It gives me hope that at least some students going through UWM's program won't be so easily carved into banal clones for shakespeare and broadway. It's really too bad that the staging of this over 100 year old indictment of bad theatre is still relevant today, and that UWM's choice to produce it stinks of hypocrisy.

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Review- Mike Daisey's If You See Something, Say Something

As i walked into Mike Daisey's show at the MCA I told Kate that as much as I've been looking forward to seeing him perform, i was a little concerned about what the show would actually be. I've heard Mike described as a "populist voice" which, i've grown to translate into "anti-intellectual whiner". After spending an hour and a half sitting 20 feet in front of him at eye level while he ranted and raved, taught me a thing or two about Herman Kahn and all but accused the audience of selling our democracy out, I can assure you he was mis-described. This guy's incredibly well structured, thoroughly researched and informative monolouge places far to high a value on individual freedom, honesty, and radical autonomy to be populist. Christ, he's sometimes downright misanthropic, complete with childhood dreams of nuclear anihilation. Populists are all about telling people what they want to hear and making promises no one could keep. Mike Daisey tells the audience that our founding fathers were terrorists, that our "security" is absurd, and that "if you think either candidate in this election will change everything, you're a fool."

Hell yeah.

Tuesday, October 7, 2008

Review - I am My Own Wife

I've decided to stop writing reviews of the theatre I see. Milwaukee's theatre community doesn't seem to be mature enough for honest criticism, but the show I saw last weekend was such a good example of a potentially great story being compromised by the prevailing norms of America's failing theatre institutions that I can't pass on this opportunity for analysis.

I am talking about "I am My Own Wife" at the Milwaukee Rep. So many people have recommended this show as this season's "if you see anything at the rep, make it this one" show. The first red flag that I may have been misdirected came when i saw that the playwright, Doug Wright had also written "Quills" a film that i thought managed to make the Marquis de Sade boring. Most of my problems are with the script. Wright makes three choices that turn a compelling character and situation into something banal enough to succeed in the current theatre environment.

First, he reduces some of the most complex situations in modern history to a simple personality drama. A play that could have been about East Germany is instead about a celebrity scandal surrounding Charlotte von Mahlsdorf and her furniture. The play even climaxes on a television talk show. Wright's American perspective, his unthinking commitment to anti-authoritarianism causes him to see this period in simple black and white, and he misses many interesting questions (questions that can be turned back on us in America today). What is it like to live under an idealistically ambitious, but deeply flawed regime? What kind of compromises does such a life demand? Instead, Wright quit writing the play when, after reading his subject's Stasi file he discovered that Charlotte had made such compromises.

This brings us to the second flaw in the script. After six years, Wright resumed work on the play with the tactic of writing himself in so his own struggle with Charlotte's integrity could take center stage. This decision allows him to write emotional lines like "I need to believe in her story, I need to believe that someone can survive in a life like hers" (paraphrased from my memory) but, in doing so it robs the audience of an opportunity to encounter that struggle ourselves. Rather than watching the contradictory facts of von Mahlsdorf's life unfold and engaging our critical capacities to understand this character, we're allowed to passively watch Doug Wright vacillate on stage.

Or, an actor playing Doug Wright, that is. The same actor who plays Charlotte von Malhsdorf and some 40 other roles. Which is the third flaw with this script. I can't find any compelling creative reason that Charlotte's story (or actually Doug's story) is best told by one actor playing all the roles. It could be argued that this choice mirrors the many lives Charlotte herself played in life, or that somehow the transvestite themes are aided by all the characters (mostly male) being played by a man in a dress. Actually, my experience is the opposite. Having one actor play all the roles dulls any edge that transvestism might have. Every time the actor switches character we are reminded that this person is onstage and wearing a costume. The potentially transgressive image of a man in a dress is constantly replaced by the perfectly acceptable even traditional image of an actor cross-dressing for his role.

I believe these decisions are motivated by economy not creativity. Wright secured the financial success and marketability of his play when he decided to make it a one man historical biopic.
When economic necessity leads a theatre artist to write, perform and otherwise create a solo show because the show is self produced and rehearsal time is shared with a day job, a job whose vacation time is spent taking the play from fringe festival to fringe festival, then the one man show is a testament to that artist's dedication to his work. When a one man play is clamoured after by large cost-cutting mismanaged regional theatres it looks a lot more like exploitation.

When politically charged content like Nazism, Communism, East-West relations and transsexual identity are replaced by a historical biography of a "greatest generation" figure, it looks a lot like pandering to the aging population of traditional theatre patrons.

When a playwright puts a character, himself even, on stage as a tool for talking about themes rather than simply portraying them, he's lazily spoonfeeding an audience he assumes is to unsophisticated or inattentive to critically engage with the characters.

Producing "I am My Own Wife" chases theatre's aging audience when what we need to do is lead or even drag new audiences into the theatre medium.

So, here again, like Endgame and Gilbert and George, we have Milwaukee's artistic establishments paying lip service to presenting politically relevant, challenging or potentially controversial work. The Rep also makes a number of design and direction decisions that exacerbate my problems with this play. Michael Gotch's performance in the show is encumbered by unnecessary sound and light cues for his character transformations. He is certainly well trained and talented enough that his voice and body alone embody the diverse array of characters for all but the most deaf and nearsighted of audience members. The light cues are like making him carry a crutch he doesn't need. The Rep also throws literally hundreds of superfluous props at the show. I must admit their production looks modest compared with the pictures from Broadway, and the props are likely in the script, but that doesn't make them any less useless. I guess a play that requires only one actor but allows the company to fill the stage with half their prop storage is just about perfect for our declining theatre world.

Monday, August 11, 2008

REVIEWS- Minnesota Fringe Fest

I saw about 25 shows last week. I reviewed a bunch of em. Loved many of them and hated a few. Here's my reviews:

Depth of a Moment
Best I've seen yet. by Rex Winsome Rating: 5 kitties
Wonderful experiments, performed with care and immense skill. Fay and Glassman present beautiful peices that necessitate active viewing, holding us in rapt attention as huge explorations of breif ordinary moments occur almost magically, before our eyes.

Deviants
Interdisciplinary dance theatre with content. by Rex Winsome Rating: 5 kitties
This show kicks ass. Deviants has got it all, raw energy, roughness, discipline, proficiency and commitment, honesty, daring, intelligence, process, surprise, alienation, emotion, action and cruelty. The spirit of Artaud is on stage with these people. MUST SEE!

elephant shoes, & olive juice; (mis) communication in a modern world
Adorable! by Rex Winsome Rating: 4 kitties
This cute show about misunderstandings, anachronistic communication mediums, and linguistic snafus exudes a genuine playfulness and simple unpolished joy of performance. Good times.

The Cody Rivers Show Presents: Stick to Glue
Insane Skills!! by Rex Winsome Rating: 4 kitties
The most manic, energetic hour of storytelling games and fun on stage you'll ever see. Completely off the hook conceptual sketch theatre. Tons of fun, but left feeling a little flat, cuz the themes were small and buried so deep you can barely find them.

Delirium for Two
Manic and Chilling and Fun by Rex Winsome Rating: 4 kitties
Don't get to see much (well, nowadays, any) Ionesco where i'm from, so it's exciting to catch this strange surreal tale of a couple trapped in an aparment under shelling. The actors range from manic to depressed with great energy and commitment. But, the performances are not consistantly believeable. The tech really steals the show here, creating startling moments of confusion and alienation that punctuate the action on stage and really up the stakes.

Leaving Normal
Amazing by Rex Winsome Rating: 4 kitties
Incredible energetic one woman show. Great physicality and control of body and face to create radically different characters and weave them into a poignant story about all the universal truths of the human condition, but with a totally unique presentation and voice that overcomes sentamentality and eschews cliche.

Boom
great new package for known message by Rex Winsome Rating: 4 kitties
A clever future times fairytale, incredibly witty and spectacularly performed, Boom tells today's story, a story we already know. The story of corporate irresponsibility, income disparity, governmental idiocy, facile pop entertainment and individual moral responsibilities. Will this fantastic packaging finally effectively deliver the message to the masses? Or is the message itself being ignored because it's not really inspiring or complete?

Gone, Gone, Gone
Accessible Modern Dance by Rex Winsome Rating: 4 kitties
Great playful and very accessible modern dance. I'm not big into dance in general, but i've seen my share of it, and this is the only concert that had me laughing out loud with the dancers. These two look great together, they are synthesizing great talent with having fun on stage like no other group i've seen.

The Butterfly Kisses Effect or A Post-Nuptial Log Flume towards Consensus
ingenious! by Rex Winsome Rating: 4 kitties
Great juxtaposition of erudite academia with insane hijinx. The best post-kitsch performance art I've seen. That's right, i just coined a new sub-genre: post-kitch. This highly personal, confessional tale by obviously well-educated people acting downright idiotic. I loved it!

Life Sciences
Sarte meets sketch by Rex Winsome Rating: 3 kitties
Like a sketch comedy No Exit, with uneven jokes, uneven performances, and a valient attempt at inserting intelligent themes into sketch comedy. Definitely worth checking out.

You're No Fun
Good try. by Rex Winsome Rating: 3 kitties
Most importantly: turn that keyboard down!!
Second: This is a show for theatre people about how theatre is growing dangerously irrelevant to non-theatre people. There were great performances and a lot of fun, but the show doesn't give what i hoped it would. It seems like a valient attempt to reach a subculture that i'd really like to see theatre reach, and it uses some wonderful Brechtian techniques to do so. Unfortunately, by the end, the message gets muddled. The characters fall into cliches and the play ends up just smashing the "modern hobo" type up against the "crazy theatre artist" type. A few scenes tap into a genuine sense of what's wrong with theatre or what's wrong with anarcho-punks, but the broadway musical resolution of these conflicts short circuits the critique. While funny and crowd pleasing, the end of the show occurs so completely within the theatre world that the play ends up more like an inward self-affirmation for crazy theatre artists, than the reaching-out to anarcho-punks I was hoping for.

All Rights Reserved: A Libertarian Rage
Spinning Wheels by Rex Winsome Rating: 3 kitties
The typical complaints from indepenent third party politicos in an often witty and occasionally funny package. Over all a pretty negatory show, espousing an ideology that seems to be defined purely by the many things it stands against.

The BoyShow
mixed feelings by Rex Winsome Rating: 2 kitties
Middle class high school boys producing a show about the issues that matter to them. It's a great thing, and some of these kids have a lot of talent. Looks like all of them had a lot of fun, too. As a play, the peice too often smacks of after school special or sex ed class mixed up with an annoying kind of untimately ineffectual politically correct liberalism.

The Gypsy and the General
Not Quite by Rex Winsome Rating: 2 kitties
Some well done loop pedal created music and really creative versatile use of a few props, resulting in a handful of unique and interesting sequences, lots of fun, but the story that tied these elements together was so utterly lacking and over acted that i found myself cringing and waiting for the next scene.

JACK
Nice Puppets by Rex Winsome Rating: 2 kitties
Lovingly told puppet version of Jack and the Beanstalk. Dreamy and langorous, visually wonderful, but the meta-theatre realization at the end leaves the peice with no where more to go.

How Does a Drug Deal Become a Decent 3rd Date?
Uninsightful by Rex Winsome Rating: 1 kitty
the male actor was funny, sometimes...

Shakespeare's Land of the Dead
Less Shakespeare. MORE ZOMBIES! by Rex Winsome Rating: 1 kitty
This peice succeeded in putting someone's excessive historical education about The Greatest Playwright of All Time (TM) to some use. It even had a good parody of Sir Francis Bacon. It's well acted and looks good too. But, it fails because it uses a zombie gimick to lure in people who don't give a rat's ass about The Bard, then dissappoints us completely. The zombie threat never seemed real or compelling. All the actual drama occuring on stage relating to the zombies had no stakes at all. The zombies were dispatched too easily to make room for more Shakespeare detrius and biographical speculation, subjects that i for one wish would just please stay dead already!

Antigone...A Riff on Sophocles
Style Clash! by Rex Winsome Rating: 1 kitty
I've heard political rallies in the 60's described as some guy on an ego trip shouting at a crowd to get free by following his every demand. This production of Antigone seems to be in that tradition. The patronizing attempt to reach a younger and more diverse demographic by inserting hip hop and modern slang creates a confused clash of styles. A genuine hiphop antigone could be good, and relevant, but this production makes ancient Greece and modern hip hop go together like plaids and stripes, with a flower power pattern of overwrought contextless symbolism scattered throughout.

The Pumpkin Pie Show
Tedious. by Rex Winsome Rating: 1 kitty
If these stories were printed on paper, they'd be mildly amusing, and you probably wouldn't make it through a collection before wanting to catch some better reading. The stories start out with an utterly uninteresting cliche, something totally ordinary and safe, then expand and deepen it until tension is introduced, and the story starts to say something. Then quickly take it a few steps further, into the ridiculous and unbeleiveable (and thus, again, safe) before wrapping it up with a silly punch line. But, I guess telling these stories with ego-maniacally bad acting somehow turns them into crowd pleasers here at the fringe.

Monday, July 21, 2008

REVIEW- Traveling Art Circus

Last night the Traveling Art Circus closed "100 Years of Nothingness" a fun three act play to a packed house at the Off Broadway theatre.

The TAC's shows fall somewhere in the range between sketch comedy, 24 hour theatre, and the fully realized play. They've got the wit, satire, pop culture references, archtypical characters and laugh a minute puns and visual gags of great sketch comedy, the random plot twists and hyperactivity of 24 hour theatre, and the length, structure and sometimes even the craft of a complete play. When these elements come together as well as they do in "100 Years of Nothingness" you get a unique and entertaining, if still quite fluffy product.

100 Years of Nothingness follows a fictional bloodline through 3 eras of pop culture icons in the last 100 years. This conceit allows the group to indulge in a wide variety of fanciful and often amazing impressions. The old timey radio programs of the 30s, the huge awards celebrations of the 70s, and a speculative unemployment line of the 2010's (from one great depression to the next) provide settings for everyone from Groucho Marx and Gertrude Stein, to Charlton Heston and Mary Tyler Moore, to Courtney Love and Hillary Clinton, and many more to share the stage in wild mash ups of debauchery, desperation and de-volution.

The history and events portrayed go beyond being merely speculative, they are totally absurd. While charming, this doesn't illuminate much, and gets a bit repetitive. Celebrity always seems to manifest as unchecked libido and abandonned responsibilities. Then mawkish themes are tacked on to these scenes with a heavy hand, and by the end of the night we're expected to see all this random fun cohere into a message that "love and art" can shore us up against all the evils and futility of the world.

But Traveling Art Circus doesn't sell itself as anything other than art for fun's sake, and they do not dissappoint. It's clear the large cast have all had a great time bringing a great time to their audience.

Thursday, July 17, 2008

Gilbert and George at MAM

I like to take the occasional day trip to Chicago, once a year or so and the MCA is always a stop on these trips, regardless of what was showing there. A few years back Gilbert and George's exhibit made this trip to the MCA somewhat dissappointing, and rather unremarkable. When i heard G+G were coming to my town i yawned, and planned to re-examine the work in light of recent changes in my perspectives on art.


The insight of years and greater sophistication has turned my yawn into a bigger yawn and a head shake of bored disapproval.


My reading of Gilbert and George's art is: they're a couple of art students who when studying Joseph Beuys and Andy Warhol decided they wanted to do the "my personality as a work of art itself" thing, and then they got shitfaced a lot and went on to do that thing, really really shallowly, but big enough that they'd get attention. These guys are a testament to the idea that alchohol and art school dampen creativity. Their large format photographs encounter issues in the most shallow and unengaging way. This is our poop. Are you shocked? Don't you poop too? What are we, preschoolers?


The sad thing is, this show (like endgame at the rep) is another awkward attempt by a large Milwaukee institution to earn some credibility by doing "provocative" art and botching it terribly. All the advertisements for the show say "brace yourself" and push the "are you angry or are you boring?" message. Traditional patrons to the museum are well-warned that they'll be offended by what they see, and people who are looking for art that speaks uncompromisingly about issues that concern them are supposed to be intrigued by these advertisements.

But Gilbert and George's work is rude enough to offend the squares without being intelligent or relevant enough to engage the enthusiasts. No one goes away happy. There are binders full of comment cards left by the veiwers of the exhibit. Most of what i saw of these cards were either: admonishing the art museum for presenting this filth, or completely bored and derogatory toward it. If the MAM is going to inspire new patrons or engage young people in art, then it needs to take a risk, and be willing to sacrifice some of the traditional patrons whose tastes are mutually exclusive with art that actually engages it's viewers.

Saturday, June 28, 2008

REVIEW- Triptych

This excellent and unique presentation of three mediums colliding in different contexts has got me thinking. Thinking perhaps unintended things, but that's what great art does, it puts the audience in a weird headspace and compells them to come to totally unexpected conclusions. But, i'm getting ahead of myself, cuz this is a review of something complex and praiseworthy, and my provoked thoughts are less important than the work itself, and with how big and complex the work, this is already going to be too long of a review.

Especially since i've gotta mention another tangent first: I stopped at Inova downstairs for a minute before Triptych started. They are displaying 5 works that were supposed to be public art back in the 80s, but apparently never made it through the beaurocracy, inspiring a playful protest by the sculptor. I love the fact that Inova is contributing some history to the present debate on the woeful state of Milwaukee's public art administration. Thank you!

Okay, on to Triptych:

Three artists' work are combined in three different ways in three different rooms refered to as "panels" in this elaborate peice. For the first panel you are ushered to the 6th floor of Kennilworth to view the three disciplines mostly isolated from each other. First you view dense complex pencil drawings by Leslie Vansen hanging in the hallways. Reading the program you discover that Vansen is a teacher at UWM and that these drawings are composed of layered manual partial reproductions of some of her students' sketchbooks. Even without this great concept, the work is engaging and interesting. Pages covered with so many patterns they become chaos, the drawings look like they should be precise things, as solid as a scientific proof or a blueprint, but the removal of certain elements and layering of so many contradictory lines make it all ephemeral, flickering with movement, impossible to look at, like a sprite in your periphery vision that flits away when you look directly at it.

The second room on the 6th floor was an experimental percussion work by Christopher Burns, played by Christopher Froh. This intriguing exploration of texture and complex rythem was incredibly precise, well performed, and dynamic. But I felt held at a distance from it. I'm used to seeing this kind of thing performed by Ettrick or Jon Mueller, in raw live performances using all the same techniques, but without the written score or the constrained perfectionism. I'm used to dancing epileptically to this kind of shit, and politely sitting in a chair with the knowledge that the end comes at the bottom right corner of the sheet of paper spread in front of the drummer takes a whole lot away from the experience for me.

The third room on the 6th floor featured Predella, a HUGE modern dance peice by Luc Vanier. Modern dance is one of the most foreign art mediums for me. I do not understand what is going on. All i can say about the half dozen modern dance peices i've seen is that i've just been impressed as hell by the dancers' ability and obvious commitment, but i haven't been able to understand or engage much with the work. I have some personal baggage in this area, ballet classes i was coerced into taking into my already awkward middle school years and a love of disorganized dionysian dancing in a crowd (even if i'm the only one) have kinda soured me on choreographed dance. This is the most unjustifiable of my many biases, and i'm glad Triptych got me more exposure by combining it with other mediums that interest me more. Especially since i felt this was the best modern dance i have seen. This conclusion might be ignorant and irritating to real dance afficianados, cuz it mostly results from the fact that with too many dancers at too close proximity i couldn't watch them all and this somehow made it more compelling.

The next panel combines these three mediums into one colloboarative interacting peice. Predella was danced to Christopher Burn's music recorded, filtered, remixed and then piped in through speakers. This apparent convention of modern dance done to recorded music is one of the things that irks me about it. This second panel defies the convention, and we get to watch smaller groups of dancers, doing more intimate work, accompanied by live vibraphone and cymbals. Projected animations inspired by Leslie Vansen and controlled by video recognition software accompany and interact with the dancers. These animations don't quite work for me, i'm not sure why, they'd make a really nice screen saver, and they don't detract from the dancers, but they are too digital, too computer generated and crisp for my aesthetic taste. Again, the dancing and the music are impressive and enjoyable.

But, its the final panel that's really got me excited about this work. The first panel introduced the three seperate artists, the second panel combined them and this third panel introduces the spectator directly into the work. You leave the room where the dancing happened and enter a maze of white sheets with more of Leslie Vansen's imagry projected on it. Scattered through this maze, side-lit by the projections, and rendered to silouette by the sheets, the dancers lie on the ground in various attitudes. A music composition made with computer scrambled vocals generated by the artists talking about the work itself fills the space and after a few minutes the audience is scattered through the maze along with the dancers. Then the recorded music stops, Froh starts playing a different version of the peice from panel one and the dancers start moving.

It's this completely unique and immersive experience that got me thinking. Throughout the final section i was aching with a temptation to somehow "touch the art" i wanted to speak to, sit by, or dance with the dancers, i wanted to move the white sheets and manipulate the images on them, i wanted to play, and i suspect that the authors of the work wanted us to play. Triptych's playbill is full of artist statements, descriptions of the works, and invitations to discuss and understand what's going on. It risks being pedantic (this is a school). Luc Vanier rode the evelvator between the floors halfway through the show with some of us, and talked genially about how two dancers had slipped and collided in last night's performance. At one point in this final section the dancers move through the maze, forcing the audience to get out of their way, and one even gently pushed me down a dead end. The art touched me.

But i still couldn't touch the art until the music stopped the curtain came up and the lights shifted to indicate that the peice was over. The art world programming is too strong, the setting somehow still to sterile, the performances too perfect and clean. I greatly commend the authors of triptych for this valient effort to break the rules of the art world from the belly of the beast, and i hope that some other audience members were more able to do their part.

Review- Gentleman's Hour

I do not like sketch comedy and improv, but last Sunday I unexpectedly found myself at The Alchemist with an hour to kill just as the Gentleman's Hour was about to start one of their bi-weekly shows. I'd heard good things about this sketch and improv group and even though my expectations for sketch and improv are generally set deeply into the negative, I've been meaning to check these guys out.

I wasn't convinced to radically change my mind on the genre, but I did find myself genuninely laughing with some frequency. More than I expected.

The show starts with a series of sketches interspersed with video, breaks for intermission and comes back for a second half of long form improv. As with other shows following this format, the improv is better than the sketch, and the video is mostly tedious. These actors are good at what they do, the writing packs in jokes, and the group occasionally defies deadly conventions enough to be interesting to someone who despises pop-culture reference, cliche and all other sketch comedy tripe.

Gentleman's Hour does sketch comedy and improv well, but does not overcome the (in my view) fatal flaws of the form. These are all things that make me bored, but they also make most sketch and improv audiences roll in the isles somehow. So, taken as suggestions, the things i need changed about sketch comedy would probably sink any sketch comedy group, as i make up a much smaller demographic than sketch comedy audiences, so i should be ignored. But i'll enumerate my needs anyway.

1. The skits fail to inform, challenge, or critically engage with the audience on anything even vaguely approaching a relevant issue or concern (what happened to meaty satire, folks?).
2. There is a lack of the unexpected or strange. Most of the jokes are predictable and unfunny.
3. The improv is not genuinely spontaneous or original. Actors pull stereo-types and ready-made characters, facial expressions, voices, and plot twists from their personal bag of tricks.
4. Irony is applied in a way that i hate. Bad jokes are made with a sigh, rolled eyes, or abrupt pauses to indicate that the joker knows how lame the joke is, which supposedly magically turns the un-funny into the funny. I am completely immune to this magic for some reason and see this technique as a cop-out, laziness on the part of the writer and or lack of talent on the part of the actor. People are funniest when they are dead serious and fully committed to their actions, no matter how absurd or stupid.
5. pop culture references. I don't watch enough TV to get most of them, and when i do get the reference i cannot understand why repeating the stuff of Hollywood or TV land is supposed to be humorous.

Tuesday, June 10, 2008

REVEIW- White Whale Collective, Borg Ward, Spackle

Some friends and I rode down to Walker's Point to check out some visual art last saturday.

We hit up White Whale Collective, the Borg Ward, and Spackle Gallery.

First stop: The White Whale Collective's 'Mountains and Anthills'. Some great work here, my favorite stop of the day. A large format pen and ink drawing by Kathleen Nelson reaches out to you as you enter the space. This woman's body as fantastical landscape rendered in beautiful black ink on rough paper gives the impression of an imagined alternative anatomy for the human body, with patterns layered over the form inviting your eye inward, to mysterious caverns created of spider web lines. Marcus Wichman's photos of exterior landscapes carefully superimposed on bare industrial interiors create visually compelling and uniquely stated commentary on urban sprawl and big-box development. But, Julia Schilling and Emily Siegel Belknap's work stand out above these and the others. Belknap's installation of a miniature wood stick fence and thin threat horizon line around the perimiter of a small room evokes the peace and comfort of the beach, while maintaining a distance through miniturization that allows us to imagine when such things will no longer be available. Julia Schilling's limited use of materials (blue ink, sheet metal, paper) create a wonderful cold formal and uninviting landscape. My favorite peice in the gallery is a sheet of metal, etched with a complex topographical map, then the blueprint of a house. This is covered in blue ink, sometimes etched away sometimes filling the grooves, and accompanied by a smaller peice with stencil cut out letters that morph into ameboa-like shapes defined by the contours of the map as they bridge the gap between the two peices and then invade the house blueprint throught he windows and door. The way this explores the relationships between domesticity, landscape, cartography and the world of platonic forms expressed through overlapping letters forming garbled text intrigues me.

After having some raspberry ginger ale with the friendly hosts at White Whale, we walked a block down to the Borg Ward. I love this place. A punk rock venue that also houses a serious art gallery, i hope they can keep it alive because the cross-medium synergy in such an accessible DIY space is inspiring.

The Borg Ward's Juried Sculpture Show is a mixed bag. There are some amazing conceptual works in mediums and processes i've heard of but haven't quite seen, especially not locally. Some less conceptual but beautifully crafted work, and some stuff that didn't really interest me at all. Madeline McGrath's soap slabs with photographic images of city streets pressed or printed or i'm not really sure how they got on there, were covered with beads of condensation that slowly wore off the image. I like to think this was intentionally planned for the humid weekend in the un-climate-controlled space, and not a happy accident, because the result was delicate, site-specific, temporary, and conceptually perfect. Viewers could see the process of gentrification degrading a unique and interesting neighborhood, replacing it with bland, clean whiteness. Other interesting conceptual works include Erin Garber Pearson's sculptures of ornamental manufactured forms sprouting with grass or hair. These works provoke a re-evaluation of these definitions. Is the sod in the music box any less artificial than the cast iron composing the box? How about the song the box plays? Another peice involving the manufacture of natural materials is the delicate and beautiful "Collar" by Ashley Morgan. The bones of a dozen or so small animals have been glued together to form a fragile sloping collar.

We left the borg ward and pedaled down to Bayview to see what Spackle had to offer. 'Peculiar Creatures, Charming Beasts' is a collection of small paintings drawings and collages from two artists, Delaney Jane Larson, from New York, and Spackle member Tara Klamrowski. Both artists create small two dimensional works that feature adorably pathetic figures as their subjects. Larson's collages and drawings evoke edward gory, but include cut out eyes from playing cards as a recognizable sign for the viewers. The peices lack the restraint and ambiguity that make Gory's work so timeless and interesting, replacing it instead with a heavy dollop of precious frowns and outright sadness (as opposed to a more interesting apathy or ennui). Klamrowski's paintings make this mistake even moreso. This work is very nice, and much more easily saleable than the large format and conceptual work at the other galleries. If you want to buy something cute to hang on your wall at NYC art gallery prices, swing by Spackle, but if you wanna see Milwaukee artists striding out toward the boundaries of artistic expression, do not miss the shows at the White Whale Collective or Borg Ward.

-Rex Winsome


--
insurgenttheatre.org
414 305 9832
rexwinsome.net

Monday, June 9, 2008

Review - Small Objects Fly Toward Heaven

I saw Deborah Clifton and Peggi Hong's Small Objects Fly to Heaven Friday night. This original collection of vignettes that flow naturally together brings the complex real world perspectives on the Iraq war to the City of Milwaukee with grace and beauty. The text was almost all derived from various blogs, presented in amusing and touching situations that center on and celebrate diversity and humanity's ability to persevere inspite of the messes we make of each other.

The content is fresh and relevant. These blog entries tell simple stories from common real-world voices struggling in extreme situations. The way Hong, Clifton and company bring these common voices together creates a historical record of the present day that approaches Barbara Krueger's ideal of history as a "crowd of voices". The show won't change your opinion much because it doesn't make a concise elegant statement on the war. It doesn't tell you what to think. Instead it trusts the audience with the competing perspectives of US soldiers, american consumers, and Iraqi civilians at the same time. We are to be informed by all equally, and are held responsible for the conclusions we draw.

At it's best, all these perspectives are portrayed sympathetically, as all valid inspite of the fact that they compete with each other. There are a few moments that fall short of this ideal. The couple shallow american girls are portrayed as cliche's of such, denying them this treatment. It's hard to sympathize with such people, but i wish the ensamble has risen to the challenge, and included a radical anti-american Iraqi perspective as well (anti-Bush bumpersticker slogans don't count, no matter how pleased the audience seemed to be with them).

At times the show slowed down or went on a tangent and it included a fair amount of new age pandering to a middle class female audience, but these flaws were tolerable distractions from the other themes in the show. Beautiful drawings and pleasant folk songs augmented the mood and setting of the play and made this celebration of womanhood (something I generally do not condone, prefering a post-gendered stance) immersive and enjoyable.

Wednesday, December 26, 2007

Review - 3 UWM shows.

We've been up to UWM to see three plays last month and didn't have time to write reviews of them in here.

First, Ring Round the Moon. This was an old school farce sort of thing, on the mainstage at UWM but it contained enough class conflict innuendo and good acting to keep me interested.

Second, Capricios. Kurt Hartwig taught a class in which they generated a full length play from scratch over the course of the semester. Everything was student led other than Kurt's suggestion of using Franscisco de Goya's Caprichios as inspiration. The final product had some interesting scenes, a nice structure, too much dependance on pop-culture references, and a lot of actors who looked very nervous to be on stage.

Third, The Dumb Waiter. This is the best thing i've seen at UWM since equus, one of the best productions i've seen in milwaukee. The small cast and crew from the player's guild clearly took the project seriously (unlike other player's guild projects i've heard of) and did the work necessary to pull off a very good production of a great Pinter play. Highlights: the sound design. Low point: the fact that it ran for only like, three days at the begining of the week. none of the people i reccommended the show to were able to attend.

Thursday, November 8, 2007

Review- Hamlet

Much to say about Shakespheare.

I am strongly of the opinion that Shakespeare is deadly theatre, that any production of Shakespeare cannot avoid falling into the wide variety of traps that have developed historically because these plays have been so over-produced, recreated “with a twist” and otherwise beaten to death. No matter what you do, you can no longer make something that’s been rehashed endlessly by everyone from Peter Brook to Hollywood, to highschools and community theatres fresh again.
Off the Wall’s production of Hamlet, running through November 11th challenges, but does not dispel this opinion. Dale Gutzman has produced some of the most engaging Shakespeare I’ve seen (and I’ve seen more than I care to recount). Maybe it’s that Hamlet is a simpler, more accessible play than most, but I don’t think so, because this simplicity is a flaw as well. The conflict of Hamlet is laid out early on, from the first scenes we know that Hamlet is going to kill Claudius, his uncle/stepdad (played well enough by Ben George) and doesn’t like it. The fact that Hamlet spends the rest of the almost three hour long play fretting over this, randomly killing other people, and just acting stupid and crazy is a major problem. It’s also the reason that I was bored silly halfway through the second act. That drowsiness fell upon me for only a short time though, and was thoroughly dispelled by the second intermission. I remained engaged through the length of the third act, which is more than I can say about most Shakespeare.
Gutzman managed to hold my attention because he took risks with this production. Some of these risks paid off (set design and blocking) others failed completely (music and sound design). The quality of the acting was very mixed, but shone most brightly when they took chances and made choices that we nothing short of inspired. Jeremy Welter’s Hamlet and Liz Mistle‘s Ophelia managed to break us out of our comfort zones and created moments of life while many of the other actors were clearly just going through the motions.
The choices of the production weren’t fresh to Shakespeare (because nothing is) but they had the energy of being fresh to this company. Unfortunately, these choices weren’t consistent. Modernizations were sometimes in stark contrast to each other in regards to costume, props and especially choice of music. This lack of consistency didn’t matter too much though, because everything was subtle enough to not be distracting.
My favorite parts of the show: the set design and blocking. Off the Wall got very creative, using every inch of their small space to create completely new locations for every scene. The set design was austere and versatile, everything was covered with one of three elements, burgundy fabric, black paint and raw wood. Moveable stage pieces, panels and sparse furniture allowed complete transformations of the space record in scene-change time. The ingenious blocking also kept the show visually interesting. Gutzman managed to keep people moving around constantly, into every corner of the stage without seeming forced or excessive. At one point these elements merged as Hamlet crossed the stage in a series of expressionistic freeze frames and then climbed up into a strange attic-like crawlspace behind the stage, delivering his “to be or not to be” soliloquy as a distant figure thirty feet away from the audience.
Some of the acting also matched this level of creativity. Ophelia’s freak-out ran the gamut of emotions with such violent transitions and changes that I couldn’t help getting caught up in it. The final duel between Hamlet and Laertes (Karl Miller) was energetic and convincing. Ophelia’s grave scene was interesting despite the TERRIBLE pandering-to-a-deadly-audience choice to have the grave-digger sing a medley of Beatle’s hits while he worked. Welter’s performance as Hamlet reached impressive intensity even though his speech and accent lapsed at times. Laertes’ confrontation with Claudius crackled with energy and I almost thought he was going to start some pistol whipping. I wish he would have.
Other moments were completely typical, actors going-through the motions, mouthing Shakespeare’s words without thinking about what they meant. I don’t think Gutzman pushed his own boundaries at all in his choices for music, and the show suffered for it. Hamlet was a spoiled emo brat who listened to crooners and showtoons, and an unnecessary soundtrack of generic “intense” music also created distraction.
There are as many different kinds of Shakespeare audiences as there are types of productions, and many of them are deadly. This show has at least a few moments to offer each type, but lacks the consistency and focus necessary to completely satisfy anyone.

Tuesday, October 30, 2007

Review- Phantasmagoria

Phantasmagoria attempted to bring a gothic history lesson to life in the format of a Victorian display of scientific oddities. The history was there, all the early influences of the avant-garde art from the gothic cannon were put on display. The format was there, the literary works were presented as if part of a pre-carnival freakshow. Unfortunately, the “bringing to life” part was mostly not there.

Much of the show failed it’s ambitions. The evening had the feel of lopsided collaboration of multiple mediums. Some people were reaching beyond what they were capable of, and some people it seems, just hadn’t done their work. The music and dance sections were the only ones that consistantly met their goals. The acting was mixed, some was very good, some of it sounded like they were reading their lines and much of it WAS people reading. The video reached too far and failed miserably, completely detracting from the rest of the production. The set and special effects also tried too hard to contribute to the mood created by the musicians, and ended up detracting from it instead.

Susie Carlson’s dancing and Brian Miracle’s acting were the saving graces that pulled their sections up over the distraction presented by the obnoxious, gimmicky video work. The other sections (most of the show) failed to overcome the low quality visuals. These visuals were conceptually interesting, two screens with a narrow play space between and rear and forward projection creating two layers of image which the actors interacted with, but the delivery was really low quality. Grainy digitized videos with fuzzy soundtracks, shoddy editing and cheap gimmicky transitions and effects ruined the ethereal gothic mood the scenic designer tried hard to achieve.

Tried too hard that is. Excessive smoke machine action set off the fire alarm early in the show and inundated the audience with intermittent hissing noises, thick clouds of smoke and an unpleasant chemical atmosphere. The intimate space made all these tech and costumes and mood effects look cheap and slapped together.

Speaking of cheap and slapped together, most of the show consisted of slide shows with actors reading narration in character (Frankenstein’s monster, Mary Shelly, Nietzsche). These sections totally disengaged me from the show and also failed to inform or interest me. I’d rather hear a lecture from a real person on these subjects or stories, without the distracting accents and half-assed characterizations, then I could’ve listened to what was being said and learnt something. As it was, the slide shows offered me an opportunity to check the time, read the program and contemplate slipping out the door.

Thursday, October 18, 2007

Review- The Internationalist

It's too bad I'm not writing reviews for Vital Source any more, cuz I saw some good theatre this week.

The Internationalist Succeeds.

The Boulevard's production of The Internationalist starring Cesar Gamino and someone else whose name I don't know cuz I didn't get a program (they don't give them out at previews), but I guess I'm not writing professionally so it doesn't matter, just like it doesn't matter where this sentence will ever end... uh... was an excellent thought-provoking piece of theatre. There we go.

The ingenious script was given free rein and proper treatment by the cast and director. It's the story of an American adrift in a foreign country, whose lack of language becomes a loss of identity as he struggles through jet lag, indulges in some eastern exoticism, and tests his integrity. The genius of the script is that half of the lines are written in a non-existent language, indecipherable by any audience member no matter how multi-culturally fluent they are. Producing this show is a challenge. If the cast fails, then the challenge transfers to the audience, and they have to sit through long sections of complete nonsense. Fortunately, the Boulevard pulls it off, without overdoing it and turning the technique into a cheap gimmick.

Gamino's performance is genuine and direct. By realistically and simply rolling with the punches of his character's complex motives and semi-delusional state, he gives the audience the treat of always being a little off balance about his next move. The woman playing opposite him also deftly handles her character's identity shifts and has a wonderful handle on the language. The supporting cast also manages the language challenge well, especially (again, I apologize for the lack of names) the curly haired guy, who's frantic anxious nervous energy made a long story-telling monologue in the nonsense language a truly bizarre theatrical moment.

Bucher's directing choices were mostly right on, even if some of the blocking seems awkward and lazy. Starting the dream sequences off like natural scenes, a generally energetic but not gratuitous treatment of the language, and minimalist set with quick scene changes kept the play moving and kept the me engaged even when the script forced the audience away from the plot by putting important exposition in the foreign language.

Thursday, October 11, 2007

Review-seascape

By Tracy Doyle

This past weekend the Milwaukee Rep opened their production of Seascape. Edward Albee’s (Who’s Afraid of Virginia Wolf and The Goat, or Who is Sylvia) 1975 drama is as engaging and timeless as ever. The play opens with a sixty-something couple on the beach, on vacation. They have lived a wonderful life together; children, successful careers, enough money to go off to the south of wherever for a week or two. The couple, Charlie and Nancy, played skillfully by James Pickering and Linda Stephens, spend most of the late afternoon discussing what they want next in life. Charlie feels he has “earned a rest”, whereas Nancy wants to travel the world, trotting from beach to beach, experiencing all life has to offer. The topics of discussion range from suspected infidelities to underwater fantasies to roaring jet planes impeding all conversation.
As the action progresses it becomes clear that Charlie is more than happy to fade away into nothing and Nancy wants them both to live life to its fullest. Throughout these exchanges, the relationship between Nancy and Charlie seems a little forced. At times, the actors feel more like they are playing caricatures of a long-married couple than really being a long-married couple; the connection is just not there. However, late in the first act, a classic Albee turn of events occurs. The twist introduces two new characters, Leslie and Sarah (Mark Corkins and Cristina Panfilio) who aid Charlie in discovering that life needs to be lived, and he admirably steps up to the plate. The chemistry between Corkins and Panfilio is undeniable; the two work together to create an irresistible foil.
This is one production where the set design, costuming, and movement choreography are phenomenal. The sometimes bland stage in the Stiemke Theatre has been immaculately transformed by Bill Clarke into a real-life, although still minimalist, “seascape.” One could almost feel the gentle sun rays warming oneself in the seats and hear the constant whoosh of the ocean waves hitting the shore. Costumes by Rachel Laritz were more than anyone could have asked for, and, in my humble opinion, really made the play.
Albee’s work is always worth seeing, and more often than not, the Rep puts forward productions well worth taking in. This show is no different. Go check it out. Take a little vacation and lose yourself in warm arguments of life and what it means; emotions and relationships. And coupling. Never forget about the coupling.

Review- Cryptogram

Another review that i have to self-publish.

A Little Too Cryptic.

Windfall Theatre's production of Cryptogram, a challenging David Mamet play, succeeds in creating a compelling evening of theatre despite failing the play's intentions. I think. I'm not sure. I'm really not sure of much about this one, but I am giddy with the mystery.

See, Cryptogram is a puzzle. It's an experiment in bizarre exposition and storytelling in a specific and mostly opaque symbolic language. Everything in the play, from the seemingly random objects an insomniac child brings downstairs, to the old picture that his adult friend puzzles over repeatedly, to an old WWII pilot’s knife, is treated with symbolic importance. Eventually, it all comes together to tell a tale of betrayal and child abuse. Or maybe it's more of a tale of neglect, or maybe the kid is just suicidal. I'm not quite sure about how the betrayal works exactly either. It’s confusing.

Watching this play, one has a feeling that, like a puzzle, there is a specific solution, which should become crystal clear by the end of the final scene. This makes it a dangerous play. Audiences are easily lost and the slightest nuance can send the play in a wrong direction, and at the end of the night, I felt like I was looking at a completed puzzle that still seemed to be missing something.

The staging and acting was good enough that even though I didn't quite "get" the play, I very much enjoyed watching it. The three person cast crafted very nice three dimensional characters that interacted with chemistry and skill. Larry Birkett was wonderfully awkward and likeable until he deftly transitioned the character into a surprising yet believable antagonist. Young Avi Borouchoff’s performance showed some great instincts and real talent. Carol Zippel’s character was disarmingly rich and deep.

In other ways, the show didn’t quite make it. The blocking was frequently really awkward. The pacing was sometimes too slow for Mamet’s trademark frantic overlapping dialog, which robbed key moments of their intensity. Hopefully, as the run goes on they can tighten these things up. Also, maybe director Shawn Gulyas was feeding us red herrings, or his own interpretation, but some of the interactions and symbols were played wrong when compared with what I could find out about other productions. With a play that’s already as difficult to follow as this one, such things lead to excessive muddling and an entertained but unfulfilled audience.

Cryptogram continues at Village Church Arts, through Oct 13th.

Tuesday, September 25, 2007

On Criticism, Community Support and Being an Upstart.

But first, a story.

Oh, wait, no, before that, a disclaimer:

The opinions contained within are the opinions of the author alone. Not of Insurgent Theatre, not of Tracy Doyle and certainly not of gmail, blogspot or any other venue that allows me to publish my opinion. I've always thought such a thing went without saying, but apparently not.

Now the story.

I see as much theatre as I can, I figure there's always something to learn from other companies, and I always have an opinion after a show. My friends and I generally share these opinions and Tracy and I actually started recording and publishing these conversations on my blog. Then, Russ Bickerstaff invited Tracy to write reviews for The Vital Source (and good god is she good at it, her reviews are not only informative, they're also witty and damn fun to read). When Russ extended that invitation to me I jumped at the opportunity.

The first play I saw as an official reviewer was 'Book of Liz' at the Boulevard. When Tracy called for the comps they had an issue with the founders of Insurgent writing reviews, but hesitantly gave us one of the two comps we requested. We had to pay for the other seat. No other company has had a problem with giving Tracy two comps even when she was just "reviewer and guest."

We saw the play and the director there made some terrible choices that damn near ruined it. My review is below, if you want specifics. Tracy wasn't very enthusiastic, so I wrote the review. I had Tracy read it for unnecessary cruelty (knowing my tendencies). I edited it by her advice and submitted it to Russ.

Russ submitted it to Vital Source, Vital then edited big chunks of Tracy-approved criticism from it and put it up. Within a few hours, this twice-softened review it was taken down. I don't have that version, but if you take off the last two sentences from the 2nd and 3rd paragraphs and the word "muck" from the review I submitted (again, find it below) you'll get close to it.

I asked Russ what was up and it turns out Vital got multiple phone calls, emails and even had someone pull their ad on account of publishing my review. I wonder what would’ve happened if it'd said what I really think.

That's the end of the story. Now for my reaction to the story. Please remember the above disclaimer, and if you have a problem with anything I say, air it with me, not anyone else.

To be concise: the fact that someone like Mark Bucher is able to censor his critics is evidence that I am living in the wrong goddamn city, that this city is too immature to have a serious theatre scene, and that artists are making the right choice when they get the fuck out.

Now to be a good deal less than concise, but hopefully more clear: my problem is not with The Vital Source, at all. If they want to edit my review, that's fine. My tone, and I’ll freely admit it is often a harsh one, may not jive with the tone they want to project. That’s their choice and their right. I also don't have a problem with them pulling the review, advertising revenue pays their bills and my opinion isn't anywhere near important enough to lose revenue over (if they backed down under advertising pressure over something less trivial, it'd be a different story.)

My problem falls squarely on the shoulders of Mark Bucher and his cronies who put Vital Source in such a position. These people obviously do not understand the nature of criticism. I think a good, honest, unrestrained, negative-but-constructive critic is something any serious theatre scene needs badly. Indeed it's something any serious artist needs. In a town like Milwaukee, many people are afraid to take that role because they risk accusations of "being unsupportive."

Thing is, groundless praise does not support a good theatre scene. It props up crap and it creates distrust of reviewers, which disempowers the audience. When you defang the critics, the audience has nothing to read but lukewarm reviews and nothing to get excited about, or to compare their experience to. When a critic with a reputation of being a curmudgeon and a jerk gives praise, it'll actually mean something, to the actors and directors as well as to the audience. It's something we need more of here.

Now, I'm willing to take on that role, regardless of how many enemies it generates. Insurgent Theatre will weather all storms. But, I don't want other people to be punished for letting me express my opinion. I can't believe I've devoted my life to making art in a city where a newspaper loses money as a punishment for honestly covering the arts. It seems this is not an isolated incident. I understand that this type of bullshit is behind OnMilwaukee.com not publishing theatre reviews anymore, either.

The fact that these local independent news sources that support the arts (often reviewing shows that others won't even acknowledge) have lost revenue because Mark Bucher's feelings were hurt by something I said is sick. Clearly these people are not only confused about the nature of art criticism, but also about the concept of community support. Attacking a newspaper because they published an opinion you disagree with is not supporting the theatre community. It's supporting one pathetic little man's ego at the expense of the rest of the theatre community.

I also take issue with Bucher and company's superficial justification for their actions, that somehow me writing a review is a conflict of interest and inappropriate. First, I call this a superficial justification, because this is not an isolated incident, and Tracy and I have just started writing reviews.

Second, it isn’t a conflict of interest because Insurgent Theatre is not competing with The Boulevard. They would never produce the kind of plays we put up, indeed, I doubt they'd ever even come and see the plays we put up. We're a DIY theatre company, reaching out to a small niche audience of young working class punks and students, not the traditional theatre audience that Bucher plays to. We're competing with local garage bands more than local theatre companies. Somehow underage punk rockers can handle this competition with the maturity and enthusiasm that is lacking in Bucher’s response.

Third, even if we were competition, it wouldn’t matter. There’s nothing wrong with reviews written by other theatre people, indeed who better to review a show than someone who produces theatre? I don't believe Tracy and I are the only active theatre producers to write a review these days. I'm totally guessing here, but I bet if you stopped every playwright, director or actor from writing reviews you'd quickly run pretty low on critics. Criticism is not a business transaction, it’s an exchange of ideas.

Forth, in case my guess is off, if nowadays only lay people are allowed to write reviews, I know it hasn't always been that way, and what's more it shouldn’t be that way. Bertolt Brecht (to use my favorite example for almost anything these days) acquired quite a reputation for writing scathing reviews of the “competitors” of his time. Surely the discussions started in these reviews contributed to his theories on theatre and helped make him one of the, if not the most influential playwright of the 20th century.

Now, I recognize that, like Brecht, I can be something of a trouble maker, that my insistence on honesty, my enjoyment of a good burn, and my refusal to get by on tact and politeness can cause trouble. But that's my choice. I'll readily absorb all kinds of hate and blame from whiney artists, bring it on. How else am I supposed to change my mind? Maybe I got something wrong, and if you tell me off I might learn something. At any rate, I love that kind of conflict because it gets close to truth and it's resolution is beautiful and educational. Conflict brings about change, development, improvement. So I welcome it.

See, I prefer achievements and a shared learning experience over appeasements and superficial friendships based on false compliments. I realize that some people can't handle that, and those are people who have a hard time being my friend. So be it. That’s unfortunate, but unavoidable, because I’m not going to moderate and sugar-coat my opinions and personality because that doesn’t give people the opportunity to prove they are not whiney little bitches. I surround myself with people who will treat me the same way, cuz there's nothing I like less than receiving praise that I can’t fully believe in.

If we treat everyone like children, no one will ever need to rise to the challenge of acting like an adult and engaging in a direct genuine interaction. So, I come on strong, I insult strangers and sometimes intentionally act like a jerk. I know that's weird and can be seen as counter-productive, but, it works for me. It's my way of doing things and my reason for doing it, and mostly, it works very well. Examples include my interaction with Monica Bennet and Faythe Levine and now in the opposite direction, the direction of someone failing to rise to the challenge, of proving unequivocally that he is a whiney little
bitch, Mark Bucher.

So, if Bucher failed the litmus test my assholery presents, then why do I care? Why have a written a fucking diatribe about it? Why didn't I just write his name in the "useless shitheads" column and move on? Because maybe talking about this, or thinking about it, or working on it, can change things.

Now, I don't think I can change Mark Bucher. He’s got twenty-two years of experience running his company how he runs it (and, hey, it’s working for him, and over the course of those twenty-two years he has done quite a bit of good.) I also doubt I can change whoever the fuck was stupid enough to pull their ad from The Vital Source over my review, but I can change other things.

If you go back to the concise version, the part where I'm talking about artists getting the fuck out of this town, you'll notice that I said "evidence" not "proof." Things don't have to be this way, and not all things are this way. There is counter-evidence, there is potential. Milwaukee's immaturity frustrates me, but it's
Milwaukee's immaturity that gives us an opportunity to make things happen here. The theatre establishment isn't quite as established as it is in other bigger cities.

I don't expect to change Mark Bucher or his audience or the people who support or appease this kind of shenanigans. Instead, I expect to build a new audience and a new community. To mobilize radical artists who are seeking more than a shelter for mediocrity, who want art that does more than “feed the soul” or in this case, the ego.

So, come on people, if the Boulevard still can't handle a negative review like adults after twenty-two years of them, they can't be that hard to shove out of our way.

Oh, yeah, here's the review that started it all:

Book of Liz Review

A modified version of this review was posted for a very short time on Vital Source Online. I've decided to publish it here for lack of another outlet. For the full story (and my opinion of the story) see the next post.

The Book of Liz at Boulevard

By Rex Winsome

The Boulevard Ensemble Theatre's Milwaukee premiere production of David and Amy Sedaris' The Book of Liz, approaches the play without the cartoonish costumes, the ludicrously artificial sets, and the other visual stunts that had New York reviewers raving about the Sedaris' own production in 2001. By stripping away all these visuals, director Mark Bucher was able to tackle this cinematic, scene-change ridden comedy with little or no budget.

The use of direct narration to describe the scenes and action might be a viable (even bold) approach to this visual, technically challenging play if the narration had been funny and stylistically consistent with the script. Unfortunately, it was neither. Instead, Bucher worked against the script, inundating this idiosyncratic play with tired gags, clichés, and lame references to pop songs (I'll never understand why adding a line from a recognizable song is supposed equal free laughs.) It does look like Bucher succeeded in not spending any money on the production itself, but not in a raw, simple "towards a poor theatre" sort of way, more of a "forget set design, lets just throw all this random kitschy stuff we've got laying around at em" sort of way.

Much of the humor of this piece managed to shine through all this muck thanks to a talented cast. Beth Monhollen played the title character wonderfully straight. She navigates the Sedaris' bizarre situations (from a religious sect devoted to cheese ball production to a pilgrim themed restaurant staffed almost entirely with recovering alcoholics) with a simple, genuine performance, making her the funniest part of the show. The rest of the cast also hit some moments perfectly, especially David Oplinger, Ruth Boulet and Kathleen Williams, but their performances lacked consistency. We probably shouldn't blame them though, because their weak points were characterized by the same kind of hamming-it-up and desperate begging for laughs that populates their director's long pre-show speeches.

My personal experiences at the Boulevard have been mixed. They've produced many excellent plays, often by playwrights that don't get much attention elsewhere in the city, but occasionally their productions slide into the kind of amateurish goofing off that practically sank this show.

Thursday, May 3, 2007

Review: Ghost, Kennilworks, UWM.

T: Okay, I think it’s recording lots of wind. Talk louder cuz the wind is blowing.
This is Tracy Doyle and Rex Winsome's first audio recorded theatrical review. What follows is a condensation of that review. They saw opening night of Kennilworks: Ghost, in the “new” UWM Kennilworth building. Have at it, kids.

T: That was, over all, was… eh?

R: Uh huh.

T: But that girl… I thought she was outstanding.

R: Not Sanyika, but the other guy was really good, too.

T: Uh yes, I don’t remember his name… He was pretty good. Sanyika, I think he’d be a good film actor.

R: When he’s serious, when he... like when he stops talking, when he starts doing this… and saying… and putting… really unnatural pauses in his...

T: Gotcha.

R: It becomes completely dead. Every time it’s something serious he does that. And it kills it. Like, at the most important times.

T: Yeah. But it’s like, I feel like he’s acting inside his head. Cuz I think it’s all going on, but it doesn’t come out of his voice or his body.

R: Huh.

T: Like I think he’s going through all the… you can be too much of a head actor. But anyway, that’s just personal things about one actor. Uh…. The show was trite. Is that the right word?

R: Cliché, yeah.

T: But you know what I liked about that poetry? That she did, which I didn’t get it until like the second poem where she talked about it or whatever. I really like that it was really bad poetry, cuz she had mentioned that she’s not very good. So that actually made sense and worked, but well, it didn’t work, cuz I didn’t like it at all. And it like, broke her, the mood, every time.

R: Totally, it was like- again, the same sort of thing, like when it’s most important to have the audience, like a transition of feeling, and they did this poem

T: That just killed everything you had just felt and you were like wow, this is shit. What I really loved though- I really loved that it wasn’t about race; it was about class.

R: Oh yeah. But at the same time… it didn’t... It didn’t ever get raw. Like the fucking- you know when he shoots him or the fucking...

T: Or when he hits the- yeah.

R: It’s still like, glorified and clean

T: Oh, it totally glorified the hood lifestyle. Oh, man, the uh, some of the other acting was pretty piss poor.

R: A lot of ‘em were dancers. So the actors aren’t dancing well and the dancers aren’t acting well…

T: Okay, here’s my thing about dance: if I couldn’t hear the movements, I’d probably like dance. But when you can hear their feet shuffling on the ground and it’s all clunky and cloddy and like, takes away from their movement.

R: It’s like choreographed fighting but it was all clean and smooth and graceful but not… like it should either be completely dancing or fucking-

T: And part of that is skill levels. But I also felt they coulda used music. I mean this fucking show, like, they had the DJ guy, they had like speakers and music. All the times they danced I don’t see why there wasn’t...

R: Yeah, there shoulda been.

T: What’d you think of the whole ensemble deal? What did that do to the story, having all those people there? And on stage all the time.

R: I think it kinda distracted.

T: The play didn’t reveal any truth or anything I’ve not heard before.

R: Right.

T: What it did is it- I hadn’t seen it on stage before.

R: It put it on stage and I’m sure there were some people there for whom it was the revealing of a truth. It woulda been much more effective if it woulda let itself be raw.

T: This is the first, well I don’t know, Top Dog, Under Dog dealt with more street issues, but in less... this was nice because it was young and it was at a college where the people are young and these are issues that some of the students might be dealing with. It did feel a little after school special-y. Well, a lot.

R: That’s the problem. That’s the only real problem with it.

T: Is this the world premiere?

R: Yeah, it’s original. It was after-school specially, some good acting

T: But it is different than other things going on.

R: Yeah, it was. It was, uh... thinking about it in terms of Brecht. And is it didactic theatre? Where you don’t have characters, you don’t have anything; you just wanna make a point.

T: You don’t have characters?

R: You don’t care about your characters. Your characters are all stand-ins. Symbols. That sort of thing. And they were all “types.”

T: The “man” and the “kid” thing.

R: The alter ego.

T: Yeah, just cuz… but you didn’t get to see any real struggle within Sanyika.

R: He didn’t have to act.

T: Cuz the other guy did it for him

R: Right. I think that splitting the character in half is a cop out, a cheat. From the writer’s perspective, and I think that detracted from it and yeah, it made it easier for the actors easier all around, made it easier for the audience and I don’t like easy theatre.

T: And those boxes, that’s the other thing I wanna say. Why didn’t they put some weight in those boxes?